Yeah, Nastia showed a potentially usable routine on beam in 2012, at a time when the leading contenders for the team were leaving a bit of a gap: Aly had just got rinsed by the E panel in Jesolo, Gabby and McKayla both had consistency issues and we all knew Jordyn’s composition was daring the D panel to do something. Of the next level down, Bross was never going to be able to hit the Patterson consistently, Li was unusable and it wasn’t really Ebee’s event. There was 100% a gymnastics case for taking a mid 14 with a very strong history of hitting beam in major competition. That’s not a loophole, it’s performance based.
Chellsie should still have been at Nationals in 2012 though, and she should be there this year too.