Nationals would’ve been justifiable in 2012 because in an Olympic year you could broadly justify anyone who had any chance at all at being top 3 on an event, and in particular anyone who had bars pedigree. While I accept that Chellsie had shown nothing whatsoever to qualify her in 2012 specifically, I wouldn’t say that would’ve been a rule bender one, since they were allowed to accept petitions.
For this year, I suppose if they do want her to qualify as of right, nothing to prevent some generous scoring. Across the board if necessary.