2022 World Gymnastics Championships WAG All Around Final (Thursday 11/03)

[Doug1233]

Right. Based on Rio and I’s scores so far (and without yet having reviewed D Panel) we have:

1. Andrade 57.0
2. Shilese 55.8
3. Kinsella 54.7
4. Gadirova 54.35
5. Black 54.2
6. Carey 53.8
7. Miyata 53.8 (tied w Carey)
8. Ou 53.7

We welcome more judges! Let me know if you want to join in and don’t already have edit access.

 

[makam]

After BB, i was like, nah, thats not right but after fx, i was well, that made up for the bb overscore. Balanced the universe.

I do wish jade could lean into her tumbling talent and make her beam better. She isn’t going to be a better dancer until she loses her self-consciousness and if that hasn’t happened with a year of college under her belt, I’m not sure it ever will. So, check as many artistry boxes as possible while building the D score as much as possible so she doesn’t have to rely so heavily on vt and fx to make up the difference.

 

[ruby]

Gadirova has invredible amplitude on her leaps/jumps and tumbling. The camera perspective does not do her justice.

 

[Doug1233]

Would Chiles TF AA score beaten Shilese for silver?

 

[Seyonne]

Quick calculation has Jordan at 55.833

 

[ArnoldRimmer]

I’ll be seeing her live this weekend and will watch with great interest!

 

[J175]

What’s gone wrong for France this week? 8th in the team final, 19th and 21st in the AA, Melanie DJDS withdrew - injured? They still could get a medal with Devillard and Boyer in event finals but so far they really haven’t lived up to their potential.

 

[Puffin]

None of the French team have looked great here

MDJDS - I don’t know what is wrong but on the other hand she always breaks my heart in finals

 

[MaryClare]

Must be a bit worrying for the French programme, 18 months away from a home Olympics

 

[Gabriel]

I have to wonder if the French federation’s shenanigans have played a role. Essentially disrupting a training regimen that has worked for years for some athletes, can’t be good for morale.

 

[RedBirdie]

Shilese Jones routines:



Jade Carey:

 

[MaryClare]

What did they do?

 

[RedBirdie]

Because I now you all love this stuff, AA by execution scores only.

Rank	Name	Vault	Bars	Beam	Floor	AA	D+E Rank	Change
1	Jones	9.333	8.066	7.9	8.2	33.499	2	1
2	Black	9.033	8.233	7.633	8.333	33.232	5	3
3	Andrade	9.566	7.6	7.533	8.3	32.999	1	-2
4	Gadirova	8.933	7.633	8.033	8.4	32.999	3	-1
5	Volleman	9.2	7.933	7.733	7.966	32.832	16	11
6	Kinsella	9.166	8.166	7.4	8.033	32.765	4	-2
7	Brassart	9.066	7.933	7.733	7.966	32.698	15	8
8	Carey	9.133	7.766	7.433	8.066	32.398	6	-2
9	Maggio	9.433	7.1	7.633	8.166	32.332	9	0
10	Ou	8.9	7.4	7.666	8.133	32.099	7	-3
11	Vaelen	8.8	8.2	6.733	8.266	31.999	11	0
12	Miyata	9.233	7.366	7.266	8.033	31.898	8	-4
13	D’Amato	9.166	7.166	7.233	8.066	31.631	10	-3
14	Kuusikko	9	7.3	7.566	7.733	31.599	13	-1
15	Godwin	8.966	7.9	7	7.633	31.499	12	-3
16	Yamada	8.966	7.766	6.933	7.8	31.465	14	-2
17	Lee	8.7	6.766	7.566	7.5	30.532	17	0
18	Friess	8.6	7.7	6.366	7.7	30.366	21	3
19	Schoenmaier	8.6	7.7	6.366	7.7	30.366	22	3
20	Brown	8.966	8.266	6.5	6.633	30.365	23	3
21	Visser	8.8	6.033	7.066	8.166	30.065	18	-3
22	Barbosu	8.9	6.866	7.133	6.733	29.632	20	-2
23	Heduit	8.533	7.466	6.633	6.8	29.432	19	-4
24	Casabuena	9	7.4	2.6	8.233	27.233	24	0

Biggest moves up: Volleman (11 places!) and Brassart (8). Biggest drops: Miyata and Henduit (4 each)

 

[Doug1233]

So now the twitter chat is that Jess supposedly grabbed the beam during her wolf turn?

 

[onodian]

how is that routine’s video not already here? I am disappointed in all of you

 

[Gymfan93]

This audience footage was filmed from another angle, and it looks like she just swung her arm:

 

[Seyonne]

Doesn’t look like a touch to me

 

[onodian]

ok imma say, after watching the routine again, I get why she got a 8.0. Not a lot on pauses here. Quite a bit of form and certainly a mid mistake on the wolf and big on the dismount, but it could be.

So there you have it. I was wrong. Enjoy this as I won’t be saying it much

 

[RedBirdie]

Look at the height Jess gets on her double pike dismount. My god.

 

[navyblue]

Yeah, I mean I think people are just not completely up-to-speed on the latest (stricter) judging shift. It used to be you could eyeball a super stable routine like Jade Carey’s or Jordan Chiles’ and be like ok yes wow no errors very good, 10.0 (hyperbole). . . but that was a time when artistry deductions on beam were not a thing, and judges apparently closed their eyes during back handsprings, and leaps were just window dressing. So in that context, a routine like Gadirova’s with two blatant errors (the wonky switch half and dismount landing) that the casual viewer can perceive seems worse than a routine like Jade’s, which ultimately scored 6 tenths lower. But it’s actually not. I’m OK with it.