I think Clark is more referring to the athletes with more eligibility left than just a 5th year.
For their 5th year, the athlete has already done four years, earned their degree. So Hoffman and Hall don’t apply, especially as some schools might not have the scholarship available.
Clark did take Jeffrey so that is hypocritical of him, but perhaps he thought it was Christian of him to take her seeing as a majority of schools wanted nothing to do with her.
I think his comments are more along the lines of if the gymnast doesn’t get what she wants, she can just leave the program. In other words, if she isn’t working hard enough, or not making line ups, etc.
He is also a master recruiter so he likely has the mindset on all the efforts that the coaches made to recruit an athlete, just so she can transfer at any moment.
Either way you take it, definitely hypocritical of him to even make the comments, even if he does actually support transfers.
But we know Jay Clark would do anything to win a national title as head coach.