Alice as things stand is the better AAer. She did have a disappointing Euros, and they should be paying more attention to international competitive results than secret domestic trials unless there’s a particularly good reason not to, but that all stemmed from one beam fall. The GB Euros would’ve looked very different had Alice stayed on in prelims. True that Amelie has more difficulty to bring back, and the DTY could be a real game changer, but of course this is the problem with selecting so early.