She was more of a finalist than a medallist in the 09-12 quad I agree, but even then, by the time Becky let up on other events she was still very clearly someone who was going to be a threat if she hit. Look at the scores she was getting last quad for hit routines. The international judges were absolutely willing to throw her the numbers, when she actually hit. That is a league better than Alice on any event. If Alice gets to the stage where she’s got a good chance of winning a medal if she stays on, then she’ll have a point.
But yes, whatever the selection criteria are going to be, they should’ve been communicated well in advance. I don’t think there’s anything intrinsically shady about asking for insurance routines, provided the requirements are sensible (and there seems no reason to trust in BG that they are). But they should be clear.
I also suspect they were probably hoping for one of the Gadirovas to qualify an individual spot. And it was at minimum a realistic possibility. It may well have happened if Jennifer had been there too.