2026 African Championships (Worlds Qualification)

[MaryClare]

I think the simplest solution would be some sort of official points system like FIFA uses to determine world rankings and tournament allocations

 

[makam]

It's too bad they can't make the first team worlds of a quad and "open" worlds and let any country send their team with ranking determining who gets invited the next time or making updated continental quotas. Because there are some emerging Asian teams, and I have hopes that Mexico is going to break through one day. I could see Europe losing one of their 13 quota spots to Asia in the next decade. Maybe they could make 1 spot a floating spot and either bestow it on the best team who missed the current quota, or a random draw of all teams that just missed.

I guess they could run an open team world cup tournament in different regions (not just over in Europe/Middle East and use the results from that and continental Champs to determine teams invited. (Tell the member nations in the Americas and Africa and Asia that if they want a chance at a worlds spot and not depend on being top 1 or 3 or whatever at the continental champs, pool some money and set the event up. If at least 5 teams show up, from anywhere in the world, top team gets a worlds spot outside continental quotas.)

As for the dual citizen issue, if bringing in outside "ringers" boosts the local interest and supports the local talent by giving them an extra teammate or two so they can actually qualify a team, then it feels okay. If the whole team is made up with the ringers, that feels wrong and shouldn't be encouraged.

 

[makam]

To some extent, the world championship and Olympics will probably need to make a determination: is it more important to them that they get the best gymnasts, or that they have geographic diversity? Both goals seem unlikely to be met at the same time.

I always felt that Worlds should be about the best gymnasts, even if that meant they were all Romanian or whatever, while the Olympics should be about diversity. At least, if your fed has the money to send a gymnast to europe/ME, the world cup circuit can qualify you. Unfortunately, that is hard to do for gymnasts living far away or from poorer feds, and the results don't carry over in any way (right?), so you keep having to do it every year. Tennis players ranking doesn't wipe clean each year so if they have to take time off to rehab an injury, they don't completely fall out of ranking (unless they were very low to begin with).

 

[Aizheng]

I always felt that Worlds should be about the best gymnasts, even if that meant they were all Romanian or whatever, while the Olympics should be about diversity. At least, if your fed has the money to send a gymnast to europe/ME, the world cup circuit can qualify you. Unfortunately, that is hard to do for gymnasts living far away or from poorer feds, and the results don't carry over in any way (right?), so you keep having to do it every year. Tennis players ranking doesn't wipe clean each year so if they have to take time off to rehab an injury, they don't completely fall out of ranking (unless they were very low to begin with).

The issue with that, to some extent, is of course that worlds currently serves as qualifier to the Olympics, and, importantly, as the only team qualifier. If you as a team don’t advance to 2027, then you also won’t be in the Olympics (again, as a team), if I understand it correctly?

Also, if worlds was about getting the “best” gymnasts, regardless of origin, then why have 2-per-country etc. rules?

 

[MaryClare]

A few people on X have raised an interesting point. Why are we celebrating France-2 taking a spot away from an African team that has a homegrown programme?