I’ve seen a certain blog argue that Urazova should have won the AA. Is there any real case for this hot take?
Yes - I posted evaluations of the top 4 in the thread here, with Urazova finishing 3rd over Melnikova.
Collectively, the Gymnaverse panel also had Urazova in 3rd with a total of 57.300, with Melnikova in 4th with a total of 56.367.
If you are talking about Gymtruthteller, take that argument and flush it down the toilet.
GTT has no clue about how gymnastics judging works and just claims personal favorites were robbed and then comes down harshly on gymnasts she doesn’t like, using a set of criteria that is not applied to the favorite ones.
The same person argued that Carey should have been 4th on floor exercise, that Skinner was robbed of VT finals outright over Carey, Skinner should have been second AA over Suni Lee, called Simone egotistical and gutless, since Biles knew USA wouldn’t win gold she forfeited, said Black deserved beam bronze, Skinner as robbed of vault gold because of some conspiracy to give Andrade vault gold after the judges handed Suni the AA gold, Suni Lee should have been 4th in AA and UB, and various other delusions.
GTT also has a love for Shang Chunsong and argued that she should have gotten the +1 over GCC.
I’m not saying there isn’t a legitimate argument for a Urazova bronze. I’m just astounded that someone would argue for her as the gold medalist.
That is kinda insane when you list all those takes.
Personally in my scoring I had Carey tied for fourth on floor, altho she loses the tie-breaker on E of course. So I don’t think that one’s insane hehe
LOL. Then what’s the rationale for her pulling out of AA, VT, and FX? Or only coming back for BB with a watered down routine she knew was unlikely to contend for gold? Usually people with that stupid Simone Withdrew Because She Knew She’d Lose take don’t actually watch any gymnastics so don’t realize that she withdrew from three finals where she was the heavy favorite. It’s novel, at least, to see it from someone who actually watches the sport outside of for a couple of days every four years.
GTT has always been unhinged, but I didn’t realize they’d gone completely off the deep end to the extent of Skinner Should’ve Been Second AA.
I’m pretty amazed that someone can be a crazed, blinkered Urazova fan at the same time as being a crazed, blinkered Skinner fan…
You kinda have to assume it has nothing to do with their gymnastics, but rather they’ve just arbitarily decided who they like and who they don’t on some other basis.
GTT makes Lauren Hopkins and Jess from
Gymnastic look like Einstein.
They do have rather diametrically opposed styles…
I do notice GTT is also particularly harsh on Biles and Douglas .
There is definitely some racist microaggressions and undertones.
Yeah, they’ve been dog whistling about Gabby for years. The only use they seemed to have for Simone was that Simone beat Gabby during her comeback.
Mirror, mirror on the wall, which is the worst take of them all?
I don’t really care about blogs or trash actors, but most friends on and off the spreadsheet I’ve talked to seem to be coalescing around the notion that Urazova was robbed of an AA medal via Gelya’s E-scores. I don’t see how she beats Andrade and Lee with her floor, though.
The Urazova vs. Gelya (vs. Listunova) preference split in hardcore fans is fascinating in that it is not at all clear-cut, and one not need to go to the bottom of the barrel to get polarizing takes. Both (or any of the three, if including Listunova) can evoke anything from adoration to irritation depending on who you ask.
I adore Urazova but I can’t have her as an AA medalist with that sort of difficulty. I’m hoping that it’s been clever coaching whilst she’s been going through a growth spurt and in the next couple of years we will see some upgrades
I was all into the 1982 acro series on ef tho. Vintage Russia
It’s also split as to which of Melnikova’s scores pass the smell test. Vault and beam have the FIG panel totally in range with Gymnaverse (beam we have her 0.1 ahead), but UB/FX have a 0.3-0.5 differential. An 8.6 for what was probably her worst UB at that point of the Games, against Urazova’s cleaner set of identical composition, made the difference for bronze alone.
Overscoring Melnikova on floor is nothing new: we only to have look back at her 2019 EF bronze over Saraiva. But her bars scores were far more reasonable in 2019, and the WWGYM panel was only (slightly) out of range during TF:
Hi! You seem to have information from the Russian WAG. Are Urazova and Listunova already training? I know Melnikova is already in Round Lake, but what about the rest?