But the judges don’t distinguish the best execution either, that’s part of the problem. A 9.9 doesn’t mean the same across rotations let alone different meets.
Which is valid. But the problem comes in with the scoring then. A floor pass of a whip half, front full and a double pike should not be able to score the same as a more difficult routine. Because the harder routine should score higher -- it's objectively harder, and it's still a sport. And...
Thank you for taking the time to translate and provide your interpretation.
Could her decision, for lack a better to word, to initially run be because of the decision to not let the athletes compete? I seem to remember she was granted AIN status (when Listunova wasn't), and they were going to...
The Australian judge after the 2008 bar final may disagree about keeping scores/deductions in the dark. U.S. fans got her email address and it got ugly for a bit.
Russian Nationals
WAG AA qualifications standings
1. Lyudmila Roshchina - 55,166 (fall on BB dismount)
2. Anna Kalmykova - 54,932 (some errors on FX)
3. Vasilyeva - 54,699 (low difficulty)
4. Angelina Melnikova - 54,266 (2 falls on BB)
Video of full coverage on day 1:
Individual routines...