She has a small arch and does have head release. Back then that would've been sufficient, as degree of arch wasn't defined. It's not like she's rigidly upright.
They wouldn't have deducted that switch ring in 2008, as the requirements were a bit less prescriptive then about head position and Nastia's was basically considered textbook. Which certainly raises questions about what we ask of gymnasts' switch rings now.
I'll be honest, I think it's impossible to know. Certainly Aimee risked Martha retaliating, but I think there are instances where it would've been worse if Martha knew she could sit Simone in any reasonable way. Having finished the book I can't answer the above one way or the other; I find it...
I'll be honest, while the "golden child" line was extremely uncalled for, I don't know if Aimee would've had as much leeway to buck Martha's choices with a less accomplished athlete. I wonder if other coaches would've preferred Aimee's style, as well, but knew their athletes would lose more...
As with most AI, that feels 90% correct and just a bit off on some things. The most glaring is that Simone did not "almost become a track athlete;" Boorman states that she could've with her physical talent. Other things are less easily described as lacking accuracy as they could read multiple...
I had slight overbalance on the handstand, feet on the sheep and the side somi, rhythm on the wolf full connection, and the hop on the dismount. But it's gorgeous, and I rewatched it several times just because.