Wow, a gymnast could have done a front tuck, a double back, and a couple A-level dance skills, and if she danced to the music well, could have made that floor final.
Wow.
No, you can do it with 2 judges. Men's NCAA does it all the time.
One way is both do D and E. Another is one does D and both do E. A third way is one does D and the other does E.
(I prefer both doing both. It's a good check for errors on the D-score.)
I will say that an approach like the 2006 men's NCAA code might actually spread scores out without losing the "magical 10s" NCAA fans (and athletes, frankly) love.
1) Cap D-scores at 4.6 with 0.2 bonus for C dismount. One way to get 4.6 is 8Cs, which every NCAA gymnast should be able to do...
Most scores would be in the 12s and low 13s.
Honestly there are quite a few NCAA routines that should score mid 9s for execution, but elite judges kind of exaggerate or even make up deductions in clean routines because they are afraid to look like they missed something. It's really a bad...
D...D + C with 0.2 bonus for the bounding D + C and 0.1 series bonus
I actually think it's silly that front aerial + side aerial doesn't get 0.1 bonus. It's not the hardest connection, but it's also not easy to do with rhythm. And if we're okay awarding split leap + side aerial or front tuck +...
I think that the team event should have:
all apparatus, 6 rotations
1 per apparatus
2-vault rule
they go to floor and vault together, and HB and UB together, so it FEELS like a team event and teams can cheer each other
women do 2 extra routines, to equalize Men vs. Women
total score
I feel like, circumstances or not, Biles was the top qualifier and the clear favorite to win in 2021, so she "wins" this thread.
Wieber in 2012 and Agache in 1984 probably had the best chances of medaling besides Biles.